If your ads produce calls and forms but few booked consultations, look at intake before you touch the ads. Leads cool fast: in a 2007 study, web leads contacted within five minutes rather than 30 had 100 times higher odds of being reached. [1] Answer calls live, reply to forms within minutes, follow up several times over the first week, and measure cost per booked consultation instead of cost per lead.
How can ads work while the schedule stays empty?
An ad’s job ends when someone calls or fills out a form. Everything after that, answering, replying, following up and booking, is intake. When a practice says its ads aren’t working, the ad account often shows plenty of leads, and the drop happens between the lead and the appointment. Spending more on ads then buys more leads that go cold the same way. This is one of the most common reasons marketing doesn’t show results.
Where do leads go cold?
- Missed calls. Most leads in the accounts we manage are phone calls: 86% for dermatology and 82% for eye surgery over the last 12 months. A call that reaches voicemail is a lead you paid for and may not get back.
- Slow replies to forms. A form answered the next morning often reaches someone who has already called another practice.
- Evenings and weekends. Many leads arrive after hours. If nobody responds until Monday, the weekend’s leads may have moved on.
- One attempt, then nothing. A single call or email that goes unanswered gets treated as a dead lead, when the person was simply busy.
- Price questions with no next step. Quoting a number and ending the call invites shopping around. Our front-desk guide covers how to answer and offer a time.
How fast should a practice respond to a new lead?
Within minutes. In a 2007 study of web-generated leads, those contacted within five minutes rather than 30 had 100 times higher odds of being reached and 21 times higher odds of qualifying. [1] For calls, that means answering live during open hours. For forms, it means a call or reply within five minutes, which usually needs an automatic alert to a named person rather than a shared inbox checked twice a day.
What should follow-up look like?
Plan several attempts over the first week, across more than one channel, and stop when the person books or asks you to.
- Within five minutes: call. If there’s no answer, send a short text where your form collects consent to text.
- Later the same day: a second call at a different time.
- Next day: a call and an email with a direct booking link.
- Over the rest of the week: two or three more touches, each offering specific times.
- After that: move the lead to a slower nurture list instead of deleting it.
Texting rules are strict, so check what your forms say before you text. Our text reminder guide covers the basics.
What should a practice measure?
Cost per lead tells you what the ads cost. Cost per booked consultation tells you what the whole system costs. Track each step for every channel:
- Leads: calls of a real length and completed forms.
- Reached: leads someone actually spoke with.
- Booked: consultations on the schedule.
- Showed: consultations that happened.
- Treated: patients who went ahead.
The step with the biggest drop is where to work first. A big drop after booking usually points to the consultation itself; our guide to structuring a consultation that closes covers that step.
Where should a practice start?
Call your own practice as a new patient and fill out your own web form, at a busy hour and after hours. Note how long each takes to get a response. Then set up instant alerts for forms, missed-call text-back where your consent rules allow, and a written follow-up plan with a named owner. A lead management system keeps the follow-up running without anyone having to remember it. It is part of how we run MedSpa marketing and Google Ads for practices. In nearly 25 years and over 1,000 client engagements, intake is where we look first when ads aren’t turning into patients.
About our figures: call shares come from the Google Ads accounts we manage for dermatology and eye-surgery practices, as reported by Google Ads on November 15, 2026, covering the previous 12 months. A lead is a phone call or a completed request form. Practices are not named. Results vary by market.
Usually because of intake: missed calls, slow replies to forms, no one covering evenings and weekends, and too little follow-up. Track leads, reached, booked, showed and treated for each channel to find the step where people drop out.
Within five minutes. In a 2007 study of web leads, contacting a lead within five minutes rather than 30 made the odds of reaching it 100 times higher and of qualifying it 21 times higher.
Several times over the first week, by phone, text where you have consent, and email, each time offering specific appointment times. Stop when the person books or asks you to stop.
Cost per booked consultation. It counts what the ads cost and how well intake turns leads into appointments, which is what fills the schedule.
Find out where your leads go cold
We’ll test your phones and forms as a new patient, measure your response times, and set up the alerts and follow-up that turn leads into booked consultations.


